Disney is officially developing “Halloweentown 5” for Disney Channel and Disney+, TheWrap first reported Oct. 22. The news lands a full 20 years after “Return to Halloweentown” closed out the original run in 2006. Who had “Marnie Piper gets a legacy sequel” penciled onto their 2026 bingo card?
The project is still in early development and hasn’t been formally greenlit, so think of this as a broom that’s been pulled out of the closet, not one that’s left the ground.
Twenty Years Is a Long Nap
Leaving a franchise dormant for two decades is odd, particularly one set in a town where it is Halloween every single day. The residents presumably did not notice the quiet. Disney+ data tells a different story, and 160 million hours streamed worldwide across the four films suggest the audience never actually left.
The Writers Behind the Magic
Lily Houghton and Ryan Koehn are penning the script, working from characters Paul Bernbaum created in 1998. Houghton wrote the horror comedy “Forbidden Fruits,” which hit theaters earlier this year, and produced Netflix’s upcoming young adult horror series “The Body.”
Koehn logged time as a staff writer on the “Gossip Girl” reboot from 2021 to 2023. Neither writer has a Halloween franchise on their resume, which is either a red flag or a wild card depending on your appetite for risk.
The Numbers Do the Talking
Streaming data makes the case for resurrection better than any pitch deck could. Last October, the 1998 original cracked Disney+’s list of its 10 most-watched Halloween movies. A 27-year-old cable movie still muscling its way into a streaming top 10? That is not nostalgia talking. That is math.
Which Marnie Shows Up
Kimberly J. Brown played Marnie Piper in the first three films. Sara Paxton stepped in for “Return to Halloweentown” in 2006, sending an 18-year-old Marnie off to Witch University. Several cast members from the original movies have said over the years they’d be game to return, but whether either actress comes back for round five remains unconfirmed. Fans will howl if Brown stays home, and their complaint would be legitimate.
What Disney Has Not Said
No director. No cast. No release date. Disney has the whole project sealed up tight, which is standard for early development but leaves everyone guessing for the foreseeable future. Great for speculation. Less great for people who prefer actual information.
Why This Writer Is Skeptical
Nostalgia is a powerful drug, and Disney has been mainlining it for years with mixed results. A fifth “Halloweentown” movie could be a warm return to form or a lazy cash grab with a pumpkin spice coat of paint. Houghton brings horror-comedy experience and Koehn brings thriller and teen-drama credits, but Halloween-specific credentials are another thing entirely. Then again, nobody predicted the “Gossip Girl” reboot would produce a “Halloweentown” sequel scribe. Life gets weird.
The Cult of Kalabar
The original film gave audiences Kalabar, a villain so gleefully over the top that he made the Sanderson Sisters look restrained. “Halloweentown II: Kalabar’s Revenge” doubled down on the family drama by handing the grudge to his son, Kal. Ignoring that lore would be a mistake, and the consequences would be specific: very angry millennials and very long midnight threads.
A Town That Never Leaves
“Halloweentown” occupies a strange place in pop culture. It isn’t prestige television. Critics never adored it. It’s a series of made-for-TV movies about a girl whose grandmother lives in a dimension where every day is Oct. 31. And yet, 160 million hours streamed. There is something stubborn and cozy about this franchise that refuses to die, and that stubbornness may be its best quality.
What Fans Actually Want
They want Marnie. They want the Cromwell family reunited. They want a town square packed with weird monsters and a plot that does not take itself seriously. No gritty reboot. No dark reimagining. Just the same goofy magic that made them beg their parents to stay up past bedtime every October. That is not a tall order. Whether Disney delivers is another question.
The Waiting Game Begins
Development is early, so the wait could stretch for years. Houghton and Koehn have time to nail the tone. Disney has time to sort out casting. Fans have time to rewatch all four films and argue about which one is secretly the best. Spoiler alert: it’s the second one, and anyone who disagrees is wrong.
Final Pumpkin-Spiced Thoughts
A fifth “Halloweentown” movie is a gamble. Nostalgia is fickle, and reviving a franchise this old is tricky. The writers have genre chops but no Halloween track record. The cast is a mystery. The release date is a blank space.
Still, the streaming numbers are hard to argue with. Somewhere out there, a millennial is already clearing their October schedule. That is the audience Disney is counting on. Hopefully, the movie earns the wait.
What’s Next
No production start date or release window has been set. Fans looking for updates on casting, a director or a premiere date will have to wait for Disney’s next official announcement on the project. In the meantime, all four “Halloweentown” movies are streaming on Disney+.
Don't stop here
Every Score. Every Story. One Home.
Breaking sports, entertainment and news from across the Total Apex network, updated all day.
Get the Full Story →
