Bing Crosby, Danny Kaye, and Rosemary Clooney in formal black attire and top hats stand on stage, surrounded by dancers in red and green costumes. The scene feels festive and lively.

Why Bing Crosby’s ‘White Christmas’ Remains One of the Most Beloved Holiday Songs of All Time

ByAshly E. Smith

We all long for a White Christmas. The peaceful way that those pristine white crystals fall from the sky create the perfect sense of calm. The scenery that they create is even better. During the holidays, the feeling is the same. No one has ever expressed this better than Bing Crosby, with his eternal holiday classic, “White Christmas”.

The Impact of “White Christmas”

Written by Irving Berlin, “White Christmas” was first presented by Crosby in the 1942 film Holiday Inn. A fan favorite for both its lyrical and melodic content, the song remains a permanent holiday staple. During World War II, the song offered comfort to soldiers and families separated by the turmoil. Originally recorded in 1942, Crosby re-recorded the song in 1947. This version is the one most commonly heard today.

With his warm baritone and relaxed, conversational singing style, Crosby vocally caresses the song with effortless perfection. Selling over 50 million copies, “White Christmas” went on to become one of the best-selling Christmas song of all time. The hit single also inspired the film “White Christmas in 1954. Crosby starred in the film as well. Today, “White Christmas” remains a major part of both the holiday season and Crosby’s legacy in general.

Similarities And Differences Between Both Versions

Both versions of “White Christmas” were arranged by John Scott Trotter, and featured backing vocals by the Ken Darby singers. Despite the similarities, both versions were slightly different. While some have noticed the differences, others may have not. Unbeknownst to many, the 1947 version replaced the 1942 version, due to master tape becoming disheveled from overuse. Nevertheless, both have that warm, timeless, nostalgic feeling that the holidays usually bring.

“White Christmas” by Bing Crosby, Courtesy of Decca Records

1942 Version

  • Less clear
  • Less defined
  • High background
  • Wax disc recording
  • Vintage sound
  • Softer vocals
  • Intimate tone
  • Less resonance
  • Subtle background vocals
  • Light orchestration
“White Christmas” by Bing Crosby, Courtesy of Decca Records

1947 Version:

  • Cleaner sound
  • More defined
  • Less background noise
  • More polished
  • Re-recorded on better disc
  • Better tape
  • Smoother vocals
  • Slightly seductive tone
  • More resonance
  • Clear background vocals
  • Polished orchestration

Although the 1942 recording is a significant part of history, it is mostly featured on special releases. Because of it’s polished presentation, the 1947 version is one that is known today. As a result, it remains the only one played on radio, included on multiple albums and multiple streaming platforms.

Bing Crosby’s Legacy Lives On

Throughout his career, Crosby has acquired numerous accolades. These honors include an Academy Award for Best Actor in 1944. Additionally, he has achieved four Grammy Hall of Fame inductions and a Grammy Lifetime Achievement Award. With his mass appeal, Crosby has indefinitely solidified his place in pop culture as a trailblazing artist. Even 48 years after his passing, Crosby remains one of the most decorated, and influential entertainers of the 20th century.

Ashly E. Smith is an author, poet, columnist, and music journalist. With her strong pop culture and entertainment backgrounds, Ashly strives to create articles that inspire as well as entertain.

More Great Content