How Long Will ‘Only Murders in the Building’ Last? Showrunner Speaks Out

The mystery-laced halls of the Arconia are far from silent. With Season 5 of Only Murders in the Building set to drop, fans aren’t just wondering “who did it”—they’re asking, “how many seasons do we still have left?” Showrunner John Hoffman has started speaking out, and the picture is still uncertain—but intriguing.

Only Murders in the Building: Teasing More Mysteries

Image from Only Murders in the Building courtesy of Hulu

In an interview with TV Insider ahead of Season 5, showrunner and co-creator John Hoffman dropped a bomb: “Nothing is at its end.” He wouldn’t confirm whether Season 5 will end with a murder or tie everything up neatly. Instead, he suggested there’s room for “more surprise” and that there could be future seasons if the writers find fresh ideas.

So the core mystery (or quip, depending on how you see it) is: the team seems open to extending the show beyond the current storyline, but nothing is locked in.

“Stretch of Credulity”—But We’re Still Buying Tickets

Hoffman also acknowledged in the interview with TV Insider what many viewers might already be thinking: how long can this conceit continue? He admitted there’s a “stretch of credulity” inherent to the show’s idea—three sleuths investigating a series of murders in the same building, season after season.

However, he follows that admission by noting how the creativity behind the scenes keeps renewing itself. New ideas from producers, current events, character dynamics—even small twists—have helped the show stay lively. Hoffman believes there are still “great opportunities to tell stories that feel relevant.”

Fans & Casting: Want More, Expect Fresh Faces

Part of what supports the show’s longevity is its cast and its guest stars. From Steve Martin, Martin Short, and Selena Gomez anchoring the core trio, to the increasingly big names appearing in supporting and guest roles, Only Murders in the Building seems to enjoy both the star power and audience goodwill needed to push forward.

Also, episodes have been building meta-narratives and pulling from real life—political intrigue, power dynamics, social observation—all of which give more avenues for storytelling than just “who killed who.” Hoffman has suggested Season 5 will feel “very different” in tone and content.

Will Season 5 Be the End? Probably Not Soon

Although there has been speculation—by fans and press—that Season 5 might serve as some kind of endpoint, none of the creators have confirmed that. Only Murders in the Building doesn’t appear to have a firm “final season” announced. Hoffman seems more focused on how the show continues rather than when it ends. In his view, as long as there’s a compelling mystery, interesting character tension, and something fresh to say, the doors at the Arconia remain open.

Final Thoughts

As Season 5 gets underway, here’s what to take away: Only Murders in the Building is not obviously ending, and the showrunner very much wants to keep it going—if the team can keep the intrigue high, the jokes sharp, and the stakes real. For fans, that means there’s cause for optimism: this isn’t a “use-up and close up shop” kind of show… yet.

Will the next seasons bring us redemption, twist upon twist, or possibly a final curtain? That remains to be seen. But one thing is clear: the mystery isn’t over, and neither is the possibility of surprise.