Netflix’s “The Four Seasons,” which premiered May 1, 2025, has garnered a generally favorable reception from critics, according to Metacritic, which assigned it a score of 64 out of 100 based on 9 reviews.
The Four Seasons: Critical Reception
Several critics have lauded the show for its comedic talent and exploration of relationships. The Independent’s Nick Hilton called it “something of a delight,” praising the comedic interplay between the talented cast. Lucy Mangan of The Guardian described it as “Tina Fey and her writing and acting ensembles on fine form,” highlighting its wit and warmth.
However, not all reviews have been entirely positive. Collider’s Ross Bonaime found the series to be a “lackluster getaway,” criticizing the underdeveloped and stereotypical characters and the slow pacing. Angie Han of The Hollywood Reporter echoed this sentiment, stating that the show “rarely gets much more memorable.”
Many critics have noted the show’s blend of comedy and drama as it delves into the complexities of long-term friendships and marriages. Mashable’s Belen Edwards pointed out that while the show has comedic elements, it leans more towards tugging at the heartstrings. Screen Rant’s Mae Abdulbaki acknowledged the “tricky tonal balance” but found the show to be an entertaining watch, largely due to its strong cast.
Cast and Performances
The ensemble cast of The Four Seasons, featuring Tina Fey, Steve Carell, Colman Domingo, and Will Forte, has been a significant point of praise. The chemistry between the actors is frequently mentioned, with many highlighting the dynamic between Fey and Domingo. Kerri Kenney-Silver’s performance has also been noted as a standout.
The Netflix series offers a modern take on the 1981 film, including the addition of a gay couple and exploring contemporary relationship dynamics. While some critics appreciated these updates, others found them to be somewhat stale or not always successful in eliciting humor.
“The Four Seasons” appears to be a character-driven comedy-drama that offers a blend of laughs and heartfelt moments. While some critics found the pacing and character development lacking, the strength of the cast and the exploration of relatable relationship issues have resonated with others. The show’s performance with a broader audience will become clearer as more viewers tune in.
“The Four Seasons” is an eight-episode comedy miniseries created by Tina Fey, Lang Fisher, and Tracey Wigfield. It is based on the 1981 film of the same name and follows three longtime couples as they navigate the challenges and joys of their enduring friendships during their seasonal getaways. The series explores the themes of marriage, friendship, and the changes that occur over time. Each season of the year is covered in two episodes, showcasing different picturesque locations and the evolving dynamics within the group. The inclusion of a diverse cast and contemporary relationship issues aims to bring a fresh perspective to the original premise.
Beyond Critical Reception
Beyond the critical reception, “The Four Seasons” benefits from the established comedic sensibilities of its creators, Tina Fey, Lang Fisher, and Tracey Wigfield, known for their work on shows like “30 Rock” and “Never Have I Ever.” This pedigree likely draws a specific audience familiar with their style of sharp wit and character-driven humor.
The show’s premise of annual getaways provides a recurring backdrop for exploring the evolution of the characters’ relationships and personal growth (or lack thereof) over time. Each seasonal setting- winter, spring, summer, and fall- not only offers visual variety but also potentially mirrors the emotional states and challenges faced by the couples.
The casting of established comedic actors like Steve Carell and Will Forte alongside the dynamic duo of Fey and Domingo creates an anticipation for strong ensemble performances. The exploration of a gay couple’s dynamics within the long-standing friendship group adds a contemporary layer to the narrative, potentially offering fresh perspectives on the themes of commitment and companionship.
The show Four Seasons’ connection to a beloved 1981 film also creates a built-in audience familiar with the core concept, while simultaneously presenting the challenge of living up to the original’s legacy. The modern updates and comedic sensibilities aim to offer a fresh take for both longtime fans and new viewers. Ultimately, its long-term success will depend on its ability to resonate with a broader audience beyond the critical response and whether it can deliver consistent entertainment and meaningful insights into the complexities of adult relationships.
