We’re officially down to five. American Idol narrowed its Season 23 lineup, and let’s just say, this year’s Top 5 is one of the most emotionally charged, genre-diverse groups we’ve seen in a long time. Sunday night’s episode pulled double duty, delivering feel-good Disney covers and heartfelt Mother’s Day tributes that had more than a few people (judges included) reaching for the tissues.
From the moment the curtain rose, it felt like a make-or-break moment. Seven contestants gave it everything they had, but only five would survive the cut. The result? A mix of raw talent, gripping personal stories, and performances that still have social media buzzing.
Slater Nalley: Atlanta’s Teen Troubadour
At just 18, Slater Nalley might be the baby of the bunch, but his voice, style, and soul are far beyond his years. Hailing from Atlanta, this folk-pop singer-songwriter turned heads early in the competition, and his acoustic spin on Bob Dylan’s “Don’t Think Twice, It’s Alright” was a standout moment on Disney Night. Even more powerful? He dedicated it to his mom, and you could feel the love in every note.
Slater’s got that rare combo of quiet confidence and poetic storytelling. Think James Taylor meets a more introverted Ed Sheeran. He’s already blowing up online with stripped-down covers and originals that hit you right in the feels. American Idol or not, this kid’s going places.
Breanna Nix: Gospel Roots, Mom Strength
Breanna Nix has become the American Idol season’s soul and not just musically. The 25-year-old from Denton, Texas, has poured every ounce of herself into her performances, often channeling her journey as a young mom chasing a dream. Her style blends gospel and pop with a touch of fire-and-faith energy that brings the house down.
Her Mother’s Day performance (yes, dedicated to her mom) was a moment. Judges were emotional. Viewers were emotional. Honestly, even the stage lighting looked emotional. Breanna doesn’t just sing, she ministers, she testifies, she connects. And if she wins the whole thing? Wouldn’t be a shock.
John Foster: Country Heart, Southern Roots
If you’re craving classic country with zero gimmicks, John Foster’s your guy. Straight out of Addis, Louisiana, John’s been delivering the kind of down-home performances that make you want to call your grandma, grab a porch chair, and listen to some Hank Williams. His smooth baritone and storytelling style feel like a throwback in the best possible way.
Throughout the season, he’s stayed consistent, never flashy, but always heartfelt. Whether he’s crooning about faith, family, or heartache, you believe every word. He’s got Nashville written all over him.
Jamal Roberts: The Soulful Surprise
Every season needs a surprise breakout, and this year, it’s Jamal Roberts. A former PE teacher from Meridian, Mississippi, Jamal started low-key. Now? He’s easily one of the most compelling voices on the show.
His Disney Night tribute to his late stepmom was pure magic, soaring vocals, raw vulnerability, the whole package. That performance earned him a standing ovation and probably a few hundred thousand new fans. Jamal’s rise feels personal because you can tell he’s still pinching himself. He’s the guy who reminds you what Idol used to be all about: ordinary people doing extraordinary things.
Thunderstorm Artis: The Veteran Vibe
Yes, that Thunderstorm Artis, you may remember him from The Voice. But now he’s back, this time on the American Idol stage, and he’s proving he’s not done telling his story. Originally from Hawaii, Thunderstorm has a vibe you don’t forget, part folk, part soul, part gospel, all heart.
His voice? Smooth like velvet, but with just enough grit to keep you hooked. His originals? Straight-up poetry. And when he tackles covers, he doesn’t just sing them — he reinvents them. Sure, some folks raised eyebrows about his return to reality TV, but hey, talent is talent. And Thunderstorm’s got plenty of it.
Who Will Win American Idol Season 23?
Sadly, the Top 5 reveal meant saying goodbye to Mattie Pruitt and Gabby Samone, both strong contenders in their own right. But now, the spotlight’s on the final five, and the finish line is in sight. Every performance from here on out could make or break a career.
With this mix of genres, backgrounds, and journeys, the American Idol Season 23 finale isn’t just shaping up to be a talent showdown, it’s a celebration of everything American Idol stands for: growth, grit, and that spark that turns a dream into something real.
So, who’s your pick to take the crown? No matter who wins, this American Idol Top 5 lineup makes one thing clear: the future of American music is looking good.
