Captain America: Brave New World Flopped Due to No Chris Evans, Says Kevin Fiege

Captain America: Brave New World was intended to set up a new era for the MCU with politically grounded storytelling. However,  that still didn’t resonate well at the box office as the film became one of the studio’s biggest misfires. Anthony Mackie, Giancarlo Esposito, and Harrison Ford couldn’t save the day as the film stumbled to an abysmal 46% score on Rotten Tomatoes, along with a $415 million at the global box office.

Captain America: Brave New World: What Happened, Bro?

Marvel Studios President Kevin Feige made a very blunt statement as to why the movie failed to gain ground at the box office. Yeah, you guessed it, the film did not have Chris Evans, who first starred as Captain America in the MCU in 2011. At a roundtable event, Feige said that Captain America: Brave New World was “the first movie without Chris Evans.”

While many were excited to see Sam Wilson take on the mantle as Captain America, the film’s dysfunctional production and numerous reshoots most likely diminished Captain America: Brave New World’s storyline and emotional impact. Tim Blake Nelson’s Leader was supposed to have a bigger role, along with a massive final one-on-one involving Sabra (Shira Haas) and Isaiah Bradley, but the film went through several last-minute changes.

Could we talk about the elephant-sized Infinity Gauntlet in the room? Marvel isn’t just dealing with the absence of Chris Evans; they’re facing audience fatigue that rivals Thor’s gym routine. From bloated Disney+ series to back-to-back feature films, Marvel’s “more is more” strategy is cannibalizing its once-pristine reputation. Hence, Captain America: Brave New World flopped at the box office, despite its $95 million opening weekend.

Fans are no longer as keen to shell out theater money for what feels like glorified season finales (Quantumania, anyone?). It’s not about how much content you churn out; it’s about making it worthwhile. Although there have been massive hits like Spider-Man: No Way Home and Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3, Marvel has been getting burned with its post-Endgame struggles (ahem, The Eternals). Fan excitement is teetering, and no one needs box office or audience stats to feel it sinking faster than Zemo’s Sokovia prison.

Final Thoughts

Doomed reshoots, a recycled Hulk fight, questionable leadership decisions, and a tone-deaf failure to trust its new face of Captain America paint a picture far bleaker than Chris Evans’ absence. Marvel, it’s time to stop asking audiences to feel nostalgic for the way things were. Give us originality. Give Sam Wilson the movie he deserves. Write a film so good that it stands on Anthony Mackie’s shoulders, not in Evans’ shadow.